Nico's Authentic Premium Pizza
  • Home
  • West Allis, WI Location
  • Pewaukee, WI Location
  • Our Pizzas
  • Locations
  • MERCH!
  • Frozen
  • Menu at DOTTIE'S
  • Frozen Menus
  • Ney's Premium Meats
  • Franchise Opportunities
  • Metcalfe's Market
  • Home
  • West Allis, WI Location
  • Pewaukee, WI Location
  • Our Pizzas
  • Locations
  • MERCH!
  • Frozen
  • Menu at DOTTIE'S
  • Frozen Menus
  • Ney's Premium Meats
  • Franchise Opportunities
  • Metcalfe's Market
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

NICO'S PIZZA AND THE METCALFE FAMILY

Picture
Picture

PROUD TO BE PART OF THE METCALFE'S MARKET PIZZA OFFERING

Metcalfe's is a fourth-generation, family owned and operated neighborhood market. In addition to their Wauwatosa location, there are also two Madison locations and Metcalfe’s On The Go at the Dane County Regional Airport. Their markets are known for an abundance of local and premium quality foods. Throughout the stores, shoppers can find “food miles” signs, indicating how many miles a product has traveled to reach the shelf. Metcalfe’s Market is home to fresh baked breads & pastries from 20 local bakeries, more than 500 varieties of artisan cheeses, Boar's Head deli meats, and the largest variety of local & organic produce in the area. Metcalfe’s has been 100% green powered since 2008. 

FROZEN AT METCALFE'S

We are proud of what we make and sell to our customers!  Our pictures are not photoshopped or staged to look a way that they are not!  What you see is what you get, and we are proud of that.  Italian and Sicilian family values and pride, combined with the best ingredients make our pizzas.  Our pizzas are ALL HANDMADE one by one, the same way they are made fresh at our restaurants.  The only difference is that we flash freeze the pizzas the VACUUM SEAL them to lock in the freshness!

THE CLASSIC

Grande's Mozzarella-Asiago blend, Nico's House Sausage, Mushrooms, and fresh red-onion slices.  Our signature zesty pizza sauce with Romano cheese and fresh garlic.  ​
Picture

THE SHARP DRESSED MAN

Grande's Mozzarella-Asiago blend, Nico's House  Italian Sausage, Sliced Pepperoni, fresh red-onion slices,  Slices of extra-sharp cheddar cheese, our signature zesty pizza sauce with Romano cheese and fresh garlic.
Picture

The Sausage

Grande's Mozzarella-Asiago blend, Nico's House Sausage,  and our signature zesty pizza sauce with Romano cheese and fresh garlic.
Picture

The Tasty Firecracker

Grande's Mozzarella-Asiago blend, Sliced Pepperoni, pickled Jalapenos, and fresh red-onion slices.  Our signature zesty pizza sauce with Romano cheese and fresh garlic, infused with Texas Pete's Hot Sauce!
Picture

AVAILABLE AT METCALFE'S MARKETS!

Picture
Metcalfe's Market 6700 W State St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213
Metcalfe's Market 726 N Midvale Blvd, Madison, WI 53705

Metcalfe's Market 7455 Mineral Point Rd, Madison, WI 53719
Picture

Magnificent Portobello w/ Sausage


Available Frozen At
​Ney's Premium Meats Slinger, WI











Picture
Picture